Paint Heroes Review: Benjamin Moore vs. Sherwin Williams — The Truth About Durability, Color & Value

Paint Heroes Benjamin Moore vs. Sherwin Williams What Brand Will Win the Battle for Your Walls?

Paint Heroes Guide: Benjamin Moore vs. Sherwin Williams The Real Winner for Your Home Walls

When it comes to lighting the atmosphere around your home by putting a clean coat of coat of paints to it, no other decision can matter more to you than the brand that you select. At Paint Heroes, our decades of direct, professional house painting work put us in the most unique position to demystify the longstanding Benjamin Moore vs. Sherwin William discussion that you, the home owners, interior designers and professional painting forces are all faced with: Benjamin Moore vs. Sherwin William.

We are not here to read labels off the outside of the paint cans, we are here to impart the practical knowledge, any excellence deficits or defects anywhere we see them, and those stratification differences that we have seen in literally thousands of homes. Trust is all important, and it is our business at Paint Heroes to defuse this paint competition by revealing all that home owners need to know. After all, when it comes to your living room, exterior siding, or trim, only the best will do, and nothing less than, from proper authority support for paint recommendations will do. If you care to look at further projects in which we have produced results on the canvas and canvases and canvases, or if you crave information on choosing the right finish on house painting and what if you do check our further extensive sites set up for you, the home owner.

Paint Heroes Benjamin Moore vs. Sherwin Williams Which Gives the True Nature of Color Effects in all Lighting?

Every home owner hopes for to have beautiful colors in true nature which never change. Both Sherwin Williams and Benjamin Moore are leaders but really, what is going on?

Benjamin Moore is well known for its Gennex color system, meaning its colors are deep and rich and do not appear to be dull under peculiar lighting conditions. Our team feels Benjamin Moore paints shine (literally and figuratively) in open concept homes or homes with mixed lighting and your ideal navy blue wall does not appear to be purple under varying shifts of daylight.

Sherwin Williams has won the heart but the ColorSnap system allows for limitless color customization and great consistency when moving from batch to batch. Homeowners who enjoy browsing through assorted paint chips or who need an absolute exact match historically many times fall in love here. Paint Heroes feel Sherwin Williams is an incredible powerhouse with giant projects (entire house repaint) when reproducibility to gallon lots is extremely important.

Takeaway: Where exact color is not an option, such as designer finishes and houses of certain periods, rely on Benjamin Moore for ultra accurate color depth. Enjoy having the color resulting in total control? Sherwin Williams will not disappoint.

Interior Durability fight: Paint Heroes tell you exactly where Brand stands with daily living

Paint is not just a matter of looks. Children, animals, sticky fingers and active kitchens means walls painted need strength but style.

Benjamin Moore's Aura and Regal lines have proprietary resins that are resistant to scuff marks even to "burnishing" (that ugly shiny spot where dirt gets removed time after time) and dimness. We recommend this paint for busy residential spaces or for tenants who want looks and durability.

Chances are, you won’t find Shrwin Williams’ Duration and Emeralds product lines an equal for any competitors’ attractiveness or durability in stain repellency and cleanability. Our crews’ experience? Less time worrying about a mess, for instance in mudrooms, baths or commercial endeavors, where the scrubbable products come to the rescue.

Notice! When it comes to real “wipeability,” its sheen that’s important. Both product lines have washable eggshells and satins out there ask somebody from an honest house painters’ organization about possible suggestions on sheen to match the room's requirements.

Performance details to the outside. How does it perform against the elements? Like a full-fledged veteran?

Exterior paint is where the brand name makes so much difference—as far as the life, beauty and costs of maintenance in the long run, if ever reduced paint usage is being contemplated. At Paint Heroes, we have seen that Benjamin Moore and Sherwin Williams can held underneath the glare and heat of the summer sun, the frigidness of the winters and the caziness of the salt water.

Like an outlawed ingredient Benjamin Moore gives us its Aura Exterior, which twelve paints with volunch discount, ultraviolet light retardiants and mildewcides. This is the final life for wooden homes or Victorian homes. It still gives the maximum strength of its color in a period when there is hardly any fading or chalkiness. One of those people who sail the blue sea and those who live in high moist clamates seem to prefer this paint as it gives them its necessary permanence in color.

Like a crusader, Sherwin Williams holds up its SuperPaints and Duration Exterior product Finishes against all weather. If you happen to live in a place where this time of year is of great width, or when it comes to seasons it runs full sun, Sherwin Williams’ colors grip hard against tha side wall and do not yield “peeling points,” which always indicates spots for repairs, etc.,’. If you’re getting the exterior surface of your home painted you should use the right type of qualified professional who knows how to pick a primer and finish coat from either company that will work with your substrate. Remember, the proper application procedures are just as important as the paint. Having said that,

Cost, Coverage & Application: Is There a Price Differential Worth It?

Now we get down to dollars and cents. First, writing a check for paint is an investment in the largest asset you own—your home. Homeowners always question whether the additional dollars used per gallon are really worth it.

Benjamin Moore: They seem to be a little more expensive by the gallon for this quality.

Sherwin Williams: Known for their competitive prices and sales.

But coverage is unequal! Benjamin Moore’s better lines of paint generally give more square coverage per can and the heavy solvent means fewer coats sometimes meaning the saving attained in the former case is a total waste. Sherwin’s paints usually come with the ultra smooth, self-leveling quality that our painters say is heaven with either brush, roller or spray application.

Conclusion by the pro painter: The two brands with fewer coats counted, resulting in labor savings also, and longer warranty lives, indicate prices on the two brands equal after all. Only making sure they are both properly applied! Usually it is in the painting service itself that lies the difference between a cheap makeover and an expensive do ahead.

Health, VOC’s & The Green Paint Enigma: Are the two companies safe? Socially, more and more they are putting the ultra-low VOC paints on the very top of the list to be commonly used in bedrooms, nurseries or homes with sensitive inhabitants. Benjamin Moore Natura and Eco Spec are leaders in zero VOC green certified coatings, with no performance sacrifices required. Among green certified builders, they are the sole choices made use of.

Sherwin Williams Harmony is another shrink film zero voc product that is loaded with anti-microbial benefits. A great choice to use in hospitals, allergy assisted homes and environments wanting to be safer and greener.

More info wanted on eco friendly building certifications? Interested in an all encompassing standard beyond just coating coverage, check out this green standards manual from This Old House.

Paint Heroes Insider Tip: Selecting the Most Applicable Brand for Your Job

Here is our candid advice: Benjamin Moore and Sherwin Williams are both powerhouses in the market for good reason. That is the good choice to make. It will vary depending on the specific needs of your house, the area you live in and what is most important to you - color richness, color steadiness, cleanability or greenfulness you can read more about understanding the effects of environmental factors here.

Here at Paint Heroes we being pros, never select the for the best paint that is the best on can label but the best that is applicable for the surface or applying. If you want perfect paint coverage for years in sharp cuts and a new feeling to be present, the best way to appreciate this quality is to hire a trained old team of painters who know the strong points and weaknesses of both. This is why our home painting experts utilize the best brands, and consult with you on the best-educated decision to achieve a perfect, long-lasting finish.

FAQ: Benjamin Moore vs Sherwin Williams:

Q: Which painting brand is better of the paints enumerated above, Benjamin Moore or Sherwin Williams?

A: Both Benjamin Moore and Sherwin-Williams are very good.

Both over decades have proven strong, but the enduring brand would depend largely upon the type of siding, exposure to sun, and the application of it. Our Paint Heroes professionals discover and apply the best conversion to your area and outside surfaces to pass the stay-forever test to your outside curb appeal.

Q: Is there a color advantage in using one brand or the other?

A: Certainly, Benjamin Moore is unexcelled in rich designer colors and special finishes, while Sherwin Williams is unexcelled in custom matching. Each system is gone through with you by our experts to obtain the optimum result, whether you desire the most current style on the scene, or the ultimate historic restoration.

Q: Is it safe in the vicinity of children and animals this paint?

A: Both companies have low and zero VOC paints which are ultra-safe, when they dry. For nursery, bedrooms, and playground areas generally we recommend them, but specify a certain brand when you begin booking you painting job.

Q: Is it worth while to hire professional painters, or can I do these others?

A: While it can be done, these high-grade paints do not express life until they have had a proper preparation, painting and finishing in a professional way. For the sort of turnaround you will love (and that gives added value), leave it to skilled house-painters who understand perfectly Benjamin Moore and Sherwin Williams.

All ready to fall in love with the house again?

See what the proper paint, rightly placed can do toward that end by booking your in-home appointment with our best-rated and let's give inspiration a chance to fulfill itself.—Paint Heroes verdict?

When Benjamin Moore vs Sherwin William gets together on the card, the winner is the brand that best fits the styles, tastes, budget, and desires of the individual home, cohort, also made efficient by the knowledgeable hands of professionals who properly care. As the leading professionals in the field of house painting and repairs for customers like you, Paint Heroes is equipped to assist you in evoking right results each time.

Paint Heroes Blog – Expert Painting Tips, Job Guides & Color Trends

Learn from Industry Professionals – The Ultimate Paint Heroes Blog Collection

Which Interior Paint Is Best for Your Home?

Is Benjamin Moore a Good Paint Brand?

Is Sherwin-Williams a Good Paint Brand?

Benjamin Moore vs. Sherwin-Williams: Which Paint Is Better?

Best Bathroom Paint Colors for 2025

Best Paint for Vinyl Siding: Long-Lasting Exterior Solutions

Painting Subcontractor Jobs: Professional Opportunities for Skilled Painters

Painting Jobs and How to Apply at Paint Heroes

Amber AndersonOctober 20, 2025